In partnership with

This email is best viewed in dark mode. If you are seeing a white background, click the Read Online link at the top of this message for the full experience.

HELP MY NEWSLETTER

Triage for sick newsletters that should be printing money

Deliverability ICU

Growth Ops

Recovery Plans

Year-End Strategy Edition

Your December engagement drop is not what you think it is

Most operators blame the holidays when their December numbers tank. They assume people are traveling, ignoring inboxes, deleting everything in bulk.

Wrong diagnosis. Your content is not the problem. Your shared IP reputation is drowning in retail spam.

Here is the real story: December is when every e-commerce brand floods inboxes with sale after sale. Shared sending pools get hammered. Inbox providers tighten filters. Your perfectly good newsletter gets caught in the crossfire.

This edition breaks down what is actually happening to your December sends, why this month is secretly the best time to test weird experiments before 2026, and the 8 fixes we recommended most in 2025 that you can implement right now.

Part 1

Why your December numbers are misleading

The holiday inbox is not a fair fight. Here is what actually changes in December that makes your metrics look worse even when your content stays the same:

Shared IP pools get trashed by retail volume

Most newsletter platforms use shared sending infrastructure. In December, e-commerce brands flood those same IPs with high-volume promotional mail. Spam complaints spike. Engagement rates drop across the pool. Your sender reputation takes collateral damage.

Result: your newsletter gets filtered harder even though you did nothing wrong.

The inbox provider tightens the filter

Gmail, Yahoo, and Outlook all adjust their algorithms in Q4. They have to. The volume of promotional mail explodes. Spam traps light up. User complaints multiply.

So they get stricter. Sender scores that cleared the primary inbox in October now land in promotions or spam. Authentication failures that got a pass in July now get rejected outright.

What this means for you

If your open rates drop 10-20% in December, that is not necessarily your content failing. It is the environment shifting. Your job is not to panic and overhaul everything. Your job is to shore up technical hygiene and ride it out.

Inbox fatigue is real but not the main driver

Yes, people get more email in December. Yes, some subscribers bulk delete or tune out. But inbox fatigue only explains part of the drop. The bigger factor is technical: your mail is literally being filtered more aggressively because the shared ecosystem is under stress.

The diagnostic

Check your spam folder placement rate in December vs. November. If it jumps 5-10 percentage points, you are seeing shared pool degradation, not content failure. The fix is not better subject lines. It is better authentication and segmentation.

What's tanking your December engagement?

Most operators blame the wrong thing when December numbers drop. Pick what you think is hurting your opens the most this month:

Part 2

Why December is the perfect month to test weird stuff

Everyone treats December like a throwaway month. Engagement is down, people are distracted, better to just coast into January and start fresh.

That is backwards thinking. December is your lowest-stakes testing window all year. Smaller engaged audience. Lower expectations. Perfect conditions to validate ideas before you bet on them in Q1 2026.

What to test in December

New content formats
Try a different structure, a new series concept, or a completely different editorial voice. If it bombs, you lose nothing. If it works, you have January's playbook ready.

Segmentation experiments
Send version A to your hot segment, version B to everyone else. Track which cohort converts better. Use that data to build smarter campaigns in 2026.

Subject line patterns
Test curiosity vs. clarity, short vs. long, emoji vs. plain text. December numbers will be lower, but the relative performance still tells you what your audience responds to.

Send time changes
Your optimal send time in March might not work in December. Test morning vs. afternoon, weekday vs. weekend. Find the pocket where your engaged readers are still opening.

Small monetization offers
Launch a low-ticket product, a one-time consulting offer, or a paid workshop. If it converts, scale it in January. If it flops, you tested it when nobody was watching.

The operators who win January are the ones who spent December validating ideas, not coasting. Lower stakes does not mean lower value. It means higher learning per risk unit.

Find customers on Roku this holiday season

Now through the end of the year is prime streaming time on Roku, with viewers spending 3.5 hours each day streaming content and shopping online. Roku Ads Manager simplifies campaign setup, lets you segment audiences, and provides real-time reporting. And, you can test creative variants and run shoppable ads to drive purchases directly on-screen.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Use code GET5K now

Part 3

The 8 fixes we recommended most in 2025

These are the issues that came up again and again this year. If you have been putting off technical hygiene, use December to lock these down before 2026 starts.

1. Authentication gaps (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)

If your authentication is not locked in, December is when you will feel it hardest. Inbox providers are less forgiving when volume is high. Missing DMARC? Weak SPF alignment? You are getting filtered.

Quick fix: Run your domain through MXToolbox and verify all three records are present and passing. If anything is missing or misconfigured, fix it this week.

2. Zombie subscriber bloat

Dead weight kills engagement metrics and tanks deliverability. Subscribers who have not opened in 90+ days are dragging your sender score down.

Quick fix: Segment inactive subscribers. Send a re-engagement campaign. Anyone who does not respond gets suppressed. Use this guide: The Newsletter Operator's Dark Secret.

3. Generic "from" names and subject lines

If your from name is "Newsletter" or "Team," you are invisible in a crowded inbox. If your subject lines sound like every other newsletter, you are getting skipped.

Quick fix: Use a real person's name in the from field. Test subject lines that sound like a friend texting you, not a brand broadcasting.

4. No clear unsubscribe path

Gmail's one-click unsubscribe requirement is now live. If you are making people hunt for the opt-out link or forcing them through hoops, you are getting spam complaints instead of clean exits.

Quick fix: Add List-Unsubscribe headers. Make your unsubscribe link prominent. Let people leave gracefully. Read this: Gmail's Subscription Hub Implementation.

5. Poor mobile optimization

Over 60% of opens happen on mobile. If your emails do not render cleanly on small screens, you are losing engagement before anyone reads a word.

Quick fix: Send yourself a test email and open it on your phone. If you have to pinch to zoom or scroll sideways, your template is broken. Fix your HTML or switch to a mobile-friendly platform.

6. No segmentation strategy

Sending the same message to your entire list is lazy and wasteful. Your engaged readers deserve better content. Your cold subscribers need different messaging. Batch and blast is dead.

Quick fix: Create three segments: hot (opened in last 30 days), warm (opened in last 90 days), cold (90+ days inactive). Send tailored campaigns to each group.

7. No lead magnet or onboarding sequence

New subscribers are your highest engagement window. If you are not hitting them with a welcome sequence that proves value immediately, you are wasting fresh attention.

Quick fix: Build a 3-email welcome sequence. Email 1: deliver the lead magnet. Email 2: show them what to expect. Email 3: ask what they need help with. Simple but effective.

8. No monetization plan

You are spending hours every week writing free content with no clear path to revenue. Your list is an asset. Treat it like one.

Quick fix: Pick one monetization pillar (sponsorships, products, services, affiliates) and build a simple offer this month. Use this tool to get started: Newsletter Ad Rate Card Generator.

December checklist

You do not need to fix all 8 this month. Pick the 2-3 that are costing you the most. Lock them down before January 1. Enter 2026 with a cleaner list and tighter technical foundation.

Your move

Use December to build 2026's playbook

Most operators waste December worrying about drops they cannot control. Smart operators use it to test ideas they have been sitting on all year.

[ ] Pick 2-3 fixes from the list above and implement them before December 20.

[ ] Test one new content format, subject line pattern, or send time this week.

[ ] Run a re-engagement campaign on inactive subscribers and suppress non-responders.

[ ] Launch one small monetization offer to test demand before scaling in Q1.

Simple re-engagement email template

Subject: Still here?

---

Hi [Name],

I noticed you have not opened one of my emails in a while. No judgment—inboxes get overwhelming.

But I want to make sure I am not cluttering your life if this newsletter is not serving you anymore.

If you still want to get these emails, click here: [confirmation link]

If not, no hard feelings. You can unsubscribe at the bottom of this email.

Either way, thank you for giving me a shot.

[Your name]

Tools for your recovery

Interactive diagnostic tools (free to use)

Use these to diagnose what is actually broken before you waste time optimizing the wrong thing.

5 Minute Newsletter Health Audit

Find the biggest leak in your funnel so you stop trying to fix symptoms instead of root causes.

The Newsletter Operator's Dark Secret

Understand why your best subscribers slip away so you stop losing buyers before you ever make an offer.

Gmail Subscription Hub Implementation

Get your brand logo showing in Gmail and make your unsubscribe process compliant before inbox providers force it.

Newsletter Ad Rate Card Generator

Turn your list into a clear, confident rate card so you can start having real sponsor conversations.

Need something specific

Hit reply and tell me what December problem is eating you. If it is fixable, I will walk you through it. If it needs a tool, I will build one.

Need hands on help

Book a free 20 minute consult

I will look at your December metrics, identify what is actually broken versus what is just noise, and give you one concrete fix you can ship this week. No pitch, no trap, just triage.

Book Your Slot

Closing orders

December is not a throwaway month

Yes, your metrics are going to look worse. No, it is not all your fault. But that does not mean you should coast.

The operators who use December to shore up technical hygiene, test new ideas, and clean house are the ones who enter 2026 with momentum. The ones who panic or go dark are the ones who spend January rebuilding trust.

Your December drop is not a mystery. It is shared infrastructure stress, tighter filters, and inbox fatigue. The fix is not better content. It is better technical foundation and smarter segmentation. Build that now and January becomes easy.

Stop treating December like dead time. Treat it like a low-stakes lab where you validate everything you want to scale in 2026.

Help My Newsletter · Inbox triage for people who would rather keep the list than burn it

December = best testing month of the year